Under $10

Fried chicken is delicious, but who knew it could be fun? It is when it's a fun toy from P.L.A.Y.! American Classic Fluffy's Fried Chicken Plush To...

Hold the ketchup and pass the dog this delightful American Classic Hot Diggity Dog Toy from P.L.A.Y.! Fun plush interactive toy provides hours of f...

Your little dog will love having Anderson Fox as a new playmate! This sweet and cuddly friend from Fluff-n-Tuff is made with a thick and durable Tu...

Crinkly slices of avocado and squeaky toast pair perfectly in this Avo-Doggo Toast Plush Dog Toy from P.L.A.Y. Adorable and colorful toy made with ...

The little guy with a mighty heart, Baby Bruce Shark from Fluff & Tuff doesn't back down from anything! Bruce is always on the move in a game o...

Diminutive yet delightful, let us introduce you to this terrific teeny teddy! Cubby Bear from Fluff and Tuff toys is an adorable little bear with a...

Darling little Dr. Noyz Duck toy, by Kong, is perfect for smaller dogs! Soft and cuddly and ready for playtime with a fun squeaker that will engage...

Super soft and super cute! Dogs love squeakers and they love balls. The 4" EZ Squeaker Chick Ball from PetLou combines both in a stuffing-free toy ...

Super soft and super cute! Dogs love squeakers and they love balls. The 4" EZ Squeaker Rabbit Ball from PetLou combines both in a stuffing-free toy...

These small toys are perfect for replacing lost/damaged toys in your Zippy Paws Burrow toys. You will receive a single squeaky toy.

Outward Hound's plush Hedgehogz is the friend your pup has been looking for! Made with soft faux-fur, this adorable plush is designed with minimal ...

Soft as can be, the HuggleFleece™ ball is perfect for indoor fetch and catch sessions! Made with synthetic lambswool and durable seams for long-las...

Mouthwatering plush toy with fun detachable parts plus a squeaker inside!Ingredients/MaterialsEco-friendly PlanetFill« filler is made from 100% pos...

Gators can be friendly when they're the Just For Me Plush Gator Toy from GoDog! Soft, plush material is made with Chew Guard Technology that adds a...

Sweater weather might just be coming to an end, but prepare your pup for warmer days with Metropawlin Pet's Kahuna the Alpaca! This smiling alpaca ...

Molly Fish is perfect for your smaller pooch. Measuring a whopping 4.5" it's a great fish to have your pup take a picture with to show off their gr...

As fun as a barrel of monkeys, these cute Monkey Miniz from Zippy Paws are perfect for replacing toys in Zippy Burrows toys and are also entertaini...

Mix things up by adding a little flavor to playtime with the NomNomz Avocado plush toy! Your pup will love the fun colors and inner squeakers while...

Friendly and fun, these plush monsters with fun, goofy faces are colorful buddies your pet will love! Fun extra-large squeaker entices your dog to ...

Soft and perfect for petite pooches, Shelly Turtle from Fluff & Tuff is ready to come out of her shell and join your little one for some fun! H...

Your little pup with adore the fun Skinny Pig Chew Guard Squeaky Plush Dog Toy! Brightly colored small toy with an embroidered comical expression a...

Dogs love peanut butter and Lulubelle's Power Plush Snif Extra Munchy Peanut Butter Plush Toy is the next best thing! Colorful and cute plush squea...

One look at this sweet face and your pup will fall in love!  Snuzzles Elephant from Kong is a cuddly soft buddy your dog will adore!  Crinkly ears,...

One look at this sweet face and your pup will fall in love!  Snuzzles Sloth from Kong is a cuddly soft buddy your dog will adore!  Crinkly ears, a ...

Adorable single unicorn replacement toys for the Unicorns in Rainbow Plush Burrow Toy from Zippy Paws. Sold individually.