Under $10

Your pup will go bananas for the Paw Lickers Banana Peanut Butter from The Peanut Principle! We know it's cheesy (...or, peanut buttery?), but it's...

With the Paw Lickers Blueberry Peanut Butter from The Peanut Principle! snacking has never been so delicious! Made in the USA with two high-quality...

The Paw Lickers Oatmeal Cookie Peanut Butter from The Peanut Principle! is simply delicious—we think your pooch will agree! Made in the USA with th...

Pumpkin spice season might not last forever, but your pooch can enjoy those warm fall flavors all year long with Paw Lickers Pumpkin Pie Peanut But...

Your cat will be licking clean not only its paws, but also the bowl and anything else it can get ahold of! This scrumptious recipe from Weruva is s...

Your dog will be licking clean not only its paws, but also the bowl and anything else it can get ahold of! This scrumptious recipe from Weruva is s...

Weruva's Paw Lickin' Chicken Recipe Plus with Chicken Breast in Gravy will leave your favorite furball begging for more! This delicious recipe is m...

Treat your furry friend to something special: a Paw or Bone Cookie from Preppy Puppy Bakery! These mouthwatering treats are made with quality, huma...

Looking for a bunny (or two!) to fill your pup's Easter basket? Hop on in and pick up a Pawbury Bunny from Pawsitively Gourmet! Hand-decorated in t...

Simple ingredients make for simply delicious treats with the PB & Blueberry Crispies by Bocce's Bakery! Wholesome oats, creamy peanut butter, a...

Peanut butter and bananas are a classic combination and Bocce's Bakery brings them together in these deliciously delightful PB-Banana Chip Soft &am...

Imagine all the furballs living life in peace...with treats, too! Preppy Puppy Bakery's Peace Cookies are just what your pup needs to start the day...

Keep your dog's tags safe and quiet (peaceful) with these fun Peace tag covers by Woofhoof. Made with durable nylon, fully lined, and assorted embr...

Spark your kitty's natural hunting instincts with this fun interactive 18" Peacock Sparkler Toy from Imperial Cat! Fun and colorful feathers and ri...

Spark your kitty's natural hunting instincts with this fun interactive 36" Peacock Sparkler Toy from Imperial Cat! Fun and colorful feathers and ri...

Peanut butter and beef?!  Your dog will think they hit the jackpot with this big, long-lasting beef cheek chew, rolled and dipped in natural peanut...

Surprise your pup with Peanut Butter Bite from Preppy Puppy Bakery ! Made in the USA with human-grade ingredients, these gourmet treats feature a d...

This cute and festive holiday treat is perfect for your very own little blossom! Makes a great stocking stuffer on its own, or buy a bunch to make ...

There's nothing quite as entertaining as seeing a dog eat a big gob of peanut butter. It gets everywhere. The dog enjoys this torment, you can be s...

Perfectly peanut buttery, the Peanut Butter Cake Ball by The Blue Cerebus Dog Bakery is the sweet treat your pooch has been waiting for! Handmade i...

Did someone say peanut butter?! Grab your pup's attention with this Peanut Butter Puppy Cake Mix from Puppy Cake! Perfect for birthdays, gotcha-day...

Dogs love peanut butter and K9 Granola Factory's Fresh Baked Donut HOLES for dogs - Peanut Butter w/ Sprinkles is the perfect anytime snack! Happy ...

Give them something to dance about! Dipped in yogurt icing, these peanut butter cookies will be the perfect mid-afternoon snack to satisfy their sw...

Who could resist the peanut buttery goodness of these Peanut Butter Grain Free Buddy Biscuits? This delicious dog snack is wheat, gluten, soy, eggs...

Who could resist the peanut buttery goodness of these Peanut Butter Grain Free Soft Buddy Biscuits? This delicious dog snack is wheat, gluten, soy,...

Training becomes more exciting with Bixbi's Peanut Butter Flavor Pocket Trainers. These soft texture, peanut butter flavor treats are sure to get y...

Peanutty poppers for perfect for pups who love peanut butter!  Savory and tasty, made from scratch with wholesome ingredients. Made in the USA. Ing...

Get ready for a fun and flavor filled treat for your favorite fur baby with Pup Cup's Peanut Butter Pup Cup! Packed with the nutty flavor your dog ...

We know you love your dog's puppy kisses! Well now your dog can enjoy Puppy Kisses as well with these yummy snacks from Two Bostons! The Peanut But...

Two years in development. Hundreds of test runs. Dozens of studies. Finally, they are ready for you, our discriminating customers. Soft & Chewy...

There's a definite reason that we always associate dogs with bones. Combine a beef shin bone stuffed with peanut butter and you've got a winner of ...

A soft density chew with healthy benefits, these delicious Peanut Butter Yogurt Sticks from Himalayan Dog Chews are a great choice for dogs of all ...

For those duck lovers out there, your dog will thank you for feeding them Weurva's Peking Ducken for breakfast, lunch, or dinner! Fill their bowl w...

Let your furry family member have their place on the tree with Bocce's Bakery Peppermint Bark Ornaments! Filled with delicious training bite treats...

Tis the season for holiday flavors and Pawsitively Gourmet's Peppermint Latte decorated cookie is made especially for your favorite doggie! Baked w...

Keep your small pet safer and more visible at night with this pink LED light by Nite-ize.  Attaches easily to collar or harness and turns on with a...

Bring the excitement of Seattles famous Pike Place Market right to your dogs bowl with KOHA Pike Place Platter! Made with tasty trout and savory sa...

We know you love your dog's puppy kisses! Well now your dog can enjoy Puppy Kisses as well with these yummy snacks from Two Bostons! What dog could...

Birthdays are so special and your birthday pup will look so sweet wearing this Birthday Girl Bandana from Mirage Pet Products! With a happy and col...

Every pooch deserves a little something special when their birthday comes around. Celebrate your furry friend's big day in the tastiest way with a ...

Your pup will be ready to party from head to paw on its special day! Really top off that look with the Party Hat from Charming! This birthday hat...

There's always reason to pawty with Huxley & Kent's Party Hat! It's trimmed with fluffy pink boa feathers and features a fun balloon pattern th...

Simple ingredients make for a simply delicious holiday treat with Pizza Our Heart Cheese & Bacon Recipe Treats by Bocce’s Bakery! Limited ingre...

Whether your pup is naughty or nice they'll love these hearty meat-packed Duck Thinkers by Plato. Net wt. 1 oz. Ingredients Duck, brown rice, brewe...

Friendly and fun, these plush monsters with fun, goofy faces are colorful buddies your pet will love! Fun extra-large squeaker entices your dog to ...

Warm your pup's heart—surprise them with the Hugglehounds Plush Sweetheart this Valentine's Day! This cute toy is made to be durable and lined with...

Meal time will never be boring again with delicious cuisine from Koha. This moisture rich Poke Tuna and Beef in Gravy entree has shreds of wild cau...

Meal time will never be boring again with delicious cuisine from Koha. This moisture rich Poke Tuna and Chicken entree has shreds of wild caught tu...