Under $10

Colorful and entertaining KONG Cat Active Scrunchie will captivate your kitty with multiple elastic bands around a soft exterior. Add in crinkle an...

Unleash your feline's inner ninja!  Your wild feline will have a blast pawing, batting, and karate-kicking these catnip-filled Balls of Furry treas...

Has your cat been eating all it's vegetables? Add some veggies to your cat's play time with the Carrot from Cosmic Catnip. This catnip Carrot is ...

Cats love a good chase and yours will have a blast with these Catnip Butterflies from Ducky World!  Crinkly wings and catnip-filled bodies will ent...

Your favorite feline will love chasing PetCandy's Catnip Squirrel! Cute handmade toy is filled with farm-fresh catnip and ready for play. Stimulati...

Give your kitty a colorful and fun toy she'll adore! Unicorns Catnip toys from Digpets are darling plush toys with curly tails and sparkly spots to...

Catomic Ball by Goli Design is colorful, hand-crafted from polyester fiber, and contains a large bell inside for a stimulating sounds your cat will...

Magical and fun, the Crackles Caticorn Cat Toy from Kong is ready to spark your kitty's natural instincts into fun and stimulating play sessions. W...

Soft, cuddly, and crinkly - KONG's CuteSeas Octopus cat toy checks all the boxes a cat requires in a favorite toy! Made of soft corduroy with crink...

Pearhead's Easter Chick and Egg cat toy set is sure to become your cat's favorite go-to toy this spring. The pastel Easter egg crinkles and the hat...

Singing might not be his strong suit, but FuzzYard's Frank Zobnatra cat toy is sure to steal the show this Halloween! This adorably undead fellow i...

YEOWWW! is our Two Bostons customer favorite brand of cat toys! Kitty will go berserk for this fish...YEOWWW! What a trip! No cotton fillers, just ...

KONG'S Holiday Pull-A-Partz Luvs cat toy is built for festive fun! This interactive toy stimulates your kitty's natural hunting instincts as they p...

No need for a real aquarium with you have this colorful Kittybelles Angelfish Toy by Lulubelles! Cute & colorful plush fish toy with organic ca...

Entertain and delight your favorite kitty with Kittybelles Cats Blue Ribbon Toy!  Soft plush with a touch of crinkle and a boost of organic catnip ...

Realistic looking and filled with stimulating organic catnip, your kitty will love the Classic Sushi Plush Cat Toy by Kittybelles! Entertaining and...

For the spicy kitty in your life, Kittybelles Fat Cat Hot Sauce Toy by Lulubelles is just right! Cute & colorful plush bottle shaped toy with o...

The perfect "brew" just for kitties, Kitty Klaw Cat Toy with organic catnip!  This stimulating and fun plush toy is durable, to provide long-lastin...

The Meowmello Stuff Cat Toy from Kittybelles will make your feline friend's day just a little sweeter! Made with soft plush, this adorable toy is s...

Now your feline friend can join in on the pumpkin spice craze with Kittybelles Meowww Spice Latte Cat Toy! Made with super soft plush, this festive...

Birthday celebrations call for extra-special toys!  Your kitty will love this organic catnip-filled Mewow Cake Cat Toy from Kittybelles!  This plus...

Pick up a pickle for your pet!  Your kitty will be enchanted with this organic catnip-filled pickle toy from Kittybelles!  The perfect shape for ca...

Everyone loves pizza and your kitty will love Kittybelles Pizza Toy by Lulubelles! Adorable plush slice of pizza toy with organic catnip and crinkl...

Kittybelles Sardine Cat Toy by Lulubelles is the next best thing to fishing for dinner! Cute plush fish toy with organic catnip and crinkle sound b...

Kittybelles' Snif Cat Toy is the plush toy of your feline's dreams! Made with soft fluff, this little stuffed jar is filled with exciting crinkle p...

Kittybelles' Snoreo Cookies Cat Toy is cute, crinkly, and full of catnip! Made with soft plush fabric, this engaging spin on a classic sweet treat ...

Surprise your feline friend with Kittybelles Sour Scratch Cat Toy! Made with soft plush, this adorable take on a popular candy is stuffed with crin...

For kitties with a sweet tooth this sweet Kittybelles Strawberry Donut Cat Toy by Lulubelles is a winner! Adorable embroidered plush donut toy with...

For the kitty who loves to mix it up, Kittybelles Toto's Pawdka Cat Toy by Lulubelles is the perfect option! Cute & colorful plush bottle shape...

For your feline toy connoisseur, Kittybelles Whisker's Whiskey Cat Toy by Lulubelles is the perfect blend! Cute & colorful plush bottle shaped ...

Your kitty will make this sweet catnip filled Lamb Chop their best buddy!  Lamb Chop is perfect for cats who love to bat, paw, kick and cuddle.  Th...

Delight your favorite feline with Huxley and Kent's Lit Donut & Peppermint Candy cat toys! This adorable and festive duo includes a plush donut...

Make everyday a celebration for your cuddly cat with Huxley & Kent's Meh' a Wish Cake cat toy! This adorable cake slice toy is made with soft b...

Give your cuddly cat a calming and blissful time with Metro Bliss Nip by Metro Paws! Made with ingredients sourced from the mountains of Asia, your...

Give your furry feline the gift of blissful play with Metro Bliss Stix by Metro Paws! Containing 5 delicious and organic Silvervine sticks, your pr...

Nip-naps Owli by Goli Design are cute and fun catnip infused toys. A great toy to help relieve boredom and provide stimulation and exercise.  Measu...

Your kitty will have a blast with these Organic Catnip Puffs toys!  Perfect for batting, pawing and chasing, these colorful fluffy toys are coated ...

Birthday celebrations call for party hats!  Your kitty will love this organic catnip-filled Party Hats Cat Toy from Kittybelles!  This plush toy is...

Colorful, hand-crafted from polyester fiber, and infused with catnip the Pom Pom Cat Balls from Goli Design will have your kitty chasing, batting a...

Why give your kitty one toy when you could give them three? KONG'S Pull-A-Partz Yarnz is a 3-in-1 toy built for excitement! This pull-apart toy inc...

Goli Design Purro Churro cat toy is made of colorful texture cotton fabric, infused with organic catnip and contains bells on both ends to make a r...

Cats love the thrill of the chase and the Safari Wand is a perfect interactive toy to get your kitty moving! At 60 inches long, these wand toys mak...

Even kitties love burritos, especially when they're filled with USDA certified organic catnip!  Your cat will love biting, pawing, wrestling and ch...

This Halloween, treat your favorite feline to a spook-tacular duo: the Kittybelles Spiderweb Donut & Black Flame Candle Toys! This frightfully ...

Normally stinky sardines aren't necessarily for play time, but we assure you that these Stinkies will be all your cat wants to play with after it g...

Bring home tons of fun for your kitty with Tons of Tails catnip toy! Dangly tails are perfect for grabbing and carrying, and the light weight is gr...

Invite your pretty kitty to snack time with the Treatos Snacks Cat Toy from Huxley & Kent! Made with soft baby plush and crinkle, your cuddle c...

With feline favorite USDA organic catnip and a crinkly sound, your favorite feline will love this baguette-shaped toy! Filled with eco-friendly Pla...